Facebook - Shropshire Business Twitter - Shropshire Business LinkedIn - Shropshire Business

Ruling on sleeping shifts pay

Care companies stand to benefit from a ruling which restricts the entitlement of carers who work “sleeping shifts” to the minimum wage.

In a landmark decision for the care sector, the Court of Appeal has ruled that carers who sleep at a client's home, when they are technically 'on call', are not entitled to the minimum wage during that period.

John Merry, head of employment law at Lanyon Bowdler in Shropshire, said the ruling would be welcomed by care companies but they needed to be careful about how to react to the ruling.

He said: “Employers who currently pay the national minimum wage for sleeping shifts should seek advice before they reduce employees’ pay in light of this judgment.

“Any reduction in pay – in the absence of a valid contractual provision enabling the reduction, which will be rare, or employees’ consent – will amount to a fundamental breach of contract, entitling employees to resign and bring claims based on constructive dismissal.

“And where 20 or more employees at one establishment are affected by a unilateral reduction in pay, collective consultation rules will need to be complied with, failing which affected employees will be entitled to protective awards worth up to 90 days’ pay.

“In certain circumstances, employers can force pay reductions in breach of contract. In the case of employees with more than two years’ service, who will have protection against unfair dismissal, there will need to be a sufficient business reason to force the change and an appropriate procedure will need to be followed – including individual consultation and a right to appeal – if liability for unfair dismissal is to be avoided.

“Employers should also bear in mind that even where a pay reduction is implemented fairly and lawfully, in the absence of binding settlement agreements, employees could still chance their arm with claims – which could put employers to considerable expense of time and, in the absence of legal expenses insurance cover, legal costs.”

Prior to the Court of Appeal’s decision, the law had been interpreted that where the worker being present at the required location was a legal or regulatory requirement, but they were permitted to sleep unless and until they were called upon, and the time spent sleeping, as well as any time spent awake actively performing duties, was to be treated as working time.

But the Court of Appeal has ruled that the correct interpretation of the law is that when such employees are asleep, they are merely available for work, and not actually working, so entitlement to the minimum wage does not apply.

John added: “This decision will be welcomed by care providers, in an industry where funding is notoriously tight and meeting a minimum wage obligation in respect of sleeping shifts has been a problem. Other sectors in which employers will benefit from this ruling are the security and hotel industries.”

Pictured: John Merry - head of employment law at Lanyon Bowdler

Record-breaking year for law firm

Income boost brings more investment

4th September 2018

New partners announced at law firm

Expansion brings new round of promotions

29th August 2018

Employment expert is appointed

Law firm welcomes new solicitor at head office

11th February 2020

New assistant joins growing law firm

Dimple takes her first steps on the career ladder

27th February 2020

Lawyers open new office in county town

Martin-Kaye Solicitors launch their latest branch in Shrewsbury

11th October 2018

Top listing for law firm team

Clinical negligence experts take title

19th December 2018

Family lawyer makes national shortlist

Inaugural awards ceremony will take place online

4th November 2020

Law firm names new partners

Seven promotions announced as lawyers target future growth

22nd September 2020

Neil wins top national award

Sales director celebrates victory

23rd November 2018

Expert warns of border delays

Legal team says conditions likely to get worse before they get better

16th April 2021

New recruits strengthen team

Law firm welcomes six new members of staff

13th January 2020

Law firm set to grow its team

Search for new trainees is launched

31st January 2019

Support for Knife Angel's visit to Telford

Law firm backs knife crime awareness project

17th March 2020

Winter workplace warning for employers

Bad weather brings a whole new raft of challenges

7th February 2020

Law firm joins national movement

Industry-led initiative promotes apprenticeships

14th February 2020