Facebook - Shropshire Business Twitter - Shropshire Business LinkedIn - Shropshire Business
http://www.connexis.co.uk http://www.aaronandpartners.com

Are you a pusher or a puller?

By Ally Yates

Are you a Pusher or a Puller? Most of us are one or the other when it comes to trying to persuade and influence people.

Persuasion is not about “Getting other people to do what I ask.” Unfortunately, this commonly held belief demonstrates a lack of understanding of both the scope of persuasion and the opportunity for using different influencing strategies. It also illustrates the lamentable fact that most of us are convinced by our own sense of rightness and that our ideas are the best.

Although academic research on influencing highlights as many as nine different styles, most of us fall into the Push or Pull category. Each style is behaviourally distinctive and each is appropriate for different situations.

Let’s start with the Push style:

Behaviourally speaking, Push style is characterised by: Proposing Content (suggesting an idea); Giving Information (providing the rationale); and Shutting Out (talking across others). The solution comes from the influencer and it’s the influencer who does most of the talking.

The Push style is the most commonly used and yet it’s only effective around 50% of the time. This may be because we are apologetic or aggressive pushers. Or we may be a misjudged Pusher, revealing our solution too early. In so doing, we under-estimate the strength of resistance we will encounter.

There are, however, times when Push works well, for example in conditions where the influencer has positional authority, where you have the expertise, where the decision has already been made, where there’s only one solution, when speed is important and you can enforce compliance.

Yet how often do you adopt a Push style when none of these conditions apply?

Take James for example – a middle manager in a multinational business. He needed to create a new direction for his team. He articulated a clear, coherent plan and instructed each of his team as to who would do what, and by when.

For him, the logic was clear, the detail was exemplary and he was in charge; the team was bound to agree. Push style was a no-brainer.

However, James had overlooked a fundamental question: How important was it that he gain everyone’s commitment to the plan? If engagement is essential, then a Pull style is much more likely to work.

Pullers use three behaviours in particular:

Building is not used as often as it should be, and unfortunately this is usually because the persuader is much more interested in his own ideas and therefore fails to harness the suggestions of others. If James had focused on engaging his team using the Pull style it would have looked more like this:

  1. James asks the team for their ideas
  2. The team offers some options
  3. James then asks questions to explore their suggestions
  4. James builds on their suggestions
  5. Together, James and the team agree a way forward.

Using this approach sees the team’s level of commitment increase in line with their engagement.

The Pull style can also be effective when influencing upwards, when there’s more than one option, where resistance is likely to be high, when there are no time pressures, where any movement is better than none, when encouraging collaboration and when coaching others to use their resources.

Yes, Pull might take a little longer and require greater listening skills, but the rewards outweigh the costs.

If you think back to the last time you tried to influence someone and were unsuccessful, the likelihood is that you opted for the wrong style or perhaps it was the right style executed poorly.

To be effective we need to be able to use both styles skilfully. Push and Pull styles of influencing have nothing to do with tone. You can Push in a thoughtful, low-key way and you can Pull in an intense manner. What differentiates each style is the behaviours involved.

Give some thought as to which style to use and why. When you’re operating as a Pusher, be clear about your proposal, give your reasons and explain what’s in it for the other party.

As a Puller, lead with questions, exercise your curiosity, believe that other people can have ideas that could be better than yours and work with those ideas, gaining engagement as you go.





Companies get to grips with HR essentials

Free workshop will offer advice to small companies

20th September 2019

Bouncing back fast...

Now is the time to plan for recovery, says Nick Jones

19th May 2020

Two 'home wins' for graduate Zara

Gymnast and coach will help to improve lives

1st October 2018

Law firm launches new HR service

Portal grants instant access to employment law support

30th April 2018

Council seeks employment land in Shropshire

Locations across county suggested in local plan

14th December 2017

Gavin proves it's never too late to learn

Businessman graduates from new leadership programme

21st October 2019

Employers need to take action

Law firm offers tribunal advice

28th June 2018

Double delight for apprentices

Award-winning success for CJ Wildlife team

15th October 2019

Exams add up for accounting students

Pass rate more than 30% above the national average

19th March 2020

Huge employment law changes on the way

Why businesses will need to adapt

4th February 2020

Taking a leap into management

Expert advice on offer at free event

28th June 2019

College maintains employer links

Teams stay in touch with local businesses despite shutdown

7th April 2020

Employment expert is appointed

Law firm welcomes new solicitor at head office

11th February 2020

Visit Shropshire welcomes Visit Britain

County town in the spotlight

13th March 2020

Businesses receive detailed guidance

Firms find out about changes to the Job Retention Scheme

24th June 2020