Facebook - Shropshire Business Twitter - Shropshire Business LinkedIn - Shropshire Business

Employers' childcare warning

Employers must take their employees’ childcare responsibilities into account when it comes to allocating shift work, a Telford solicitor has warned.

John Mehtam, employment law specialist at Martin-Kaye Solicitors pictured below, said the warning followed a case where an employee won a sex discrimination claim after her request for flexible working was refused.

“The employee had worked as cabin crew for an airline for 13 years, working full time on a flexible rota, meaning she could be required to work on any 22 days in a month.

“But when she asked to return to work after her maternity leave on a fixed, pre-arranged rota of 11 days a month, her employers turned her down.

"She said she had difficulty finding nursery placements for her child dur to her unusual working hours, and so was proposing flexible working or job sharing.

“Both requests were turned down by the airline, and after appealing to the company internally, she took them to a tribunal, saying that the working arrangements placed female cabin crew at a disadvantage compared to their male colleagues.”

Mr Mehtam said the airline told the tribunal that the employee’s request for flexible hours had been fully considered, but that it could cause problems. They also said they had a fixed rota system in place and shifts could be swapped.

“The tribunal judge said cabin crew work was dominated by women mainly of child-bearing age and so agreed they were placed at a disadvantage compared with men – so they allowed the employee’s claim for sex discrimination but she lost the claim for flexible working.

“This case could be extremely significant moving forward as it could lead to flexible working schemes being adopted by female cabin crew staff at other airlines across the UK and beyond.

“It will certainly give airlines food for thought when it comes to the way they allocate hours so they don’t breach discrimination laws.

“And it’s not just airlines either, as it’s difficult to see how any other industry could argue that it would not be reasonable for them to take people’s childcare responsibilities into consideration in the same way.”


Warning for employers after tribunal

Overweight employees given extra protection in workplace

28th January 2017

Data rules - a hot topic

Presentation hosted by county solicitors

5th January 2018

Beware disclosing confidential information

'Off the record' a meaningless phrase legally, says solicitor

26th May 2017

Workplace headscarf ban - local reaction

European law courts issue landmark ruling 

15th March 2017

Employment lawyer takes top award

John wins Business Professional of the Year title

27th October 2017

Mobile phones misery for employers

Penalties not just for law-breaking drivers

5th May 2017

Law firm appoints new conveyancer

Sharanjit bolsters team at Martin-Kaye

9th September 2017

Selling a business can be tricky

There are ways of easing the process, says Telford lawyer

27th March 2017

New service boost for retirement plans

Equishield launched by Shropshire solicitors

15th June 2017

Employers could face legal action

Workers must be protected against sexual harassment

15th September 2017

Lawyers' seminar hailed a success

Employment law blunders in focus

4th July 2017

Employment law seminar success

Telford law firm's employment law advice 

17th October 2016

No one exempt from data rules

Clubs and societies warned they must comply with GDPR

28th March 2018

Are networking events a data risk?

Telford lawyer sheds light on the matter

2nd May 2018

Change in the air for will-making laws?

Consultation a positive step in overdue process, says specialist

10th August 2017